Houla massacre

From A Closer Look On Syria
(Redirected from The Houla massacre)
Jump to: navigation, search
All articles: Category:Houla

This mass-killing occurred in the in the town of Taldou (Tal-Daw), the southernmost portion of the cluster of villages known as Al-Houla (northwest of Homs). The massacre was carried out at various locations over the afternoon and evening of May 25 (and perhaps into the 26th), 2012. The most widely cited death toll is 108, including 49 children, 34 women, and 25 men. Most of these were killed inside their homes, after reported shelling of the city had killed others previously. By and large, the Syrian government has been blamed, with alleged witnesses and survivors describing an attack by their forces on families thought disloyal or too Sunni. The government and some witnesses counter that rebel terrorists attacked the town and killed various loyalist and/or non-Sunni families.

After the massacre the town, including the massacre sites and the mosque where the bodies were displayed, was controlled by the rebels, allowing them to control the news coverage and perhaps to coach the witnesses. Accounts differ on when and how the town came into rebel possession.

Cover Art-4.png

The following material on this page is only the most basic summary of each point, but serves to at least lay the relevant points out side-by-side. It needs to be updated soon. But the material at the pages linked is quite detailed in spots. For some further aspects not necessarily covered below, see the page Houla:Connecting The Dots. For a fairly comprehensive overview of Houla massacre revisionist studies, including a few of the most important highlights of our work here, see the May, 2013 report Official Truth, Real Truth, and Impunity for the Syrian Houla Massacre of May, 2012. Released by the Citizen's Investigation into War Crimes in Libya (run by wiki members), 79-page PDF available here.

Scene

Main article: Houla:Scene

The intensively illustrated page explores the city and its crime scenes in detail. Various maps and location-related sources are compared and distilled into best readings. There's a street-level visual tour up 'Main Street,' revealing telling details of what happened (it was violent and widespread). The overrun and/or abandoned security posts are examined in passing, along with the mosque and mass grave site, the various massacre sites, and some other places and things, like a dead goat.

Below left: The towns of Al-Houla and their position relative to Homs and Ar-Rastan, both hotbeds of FSA activity. Below right: Taldou itself. The crime scenes are mostly on the southern edge.

Map Homs Houla Rastan.png Taldou sat.jpg

Main article: Houla, May 25: Who Was in Control?

Another page uses that spatial understanding (see map below) and many of the visual clues to explore the very real possibility that the government's forces lost control of the city to rebel attackers on May 25, in the hours prior to the massacres. The work is still open, but has had amazing results, really, later condensed into this [http://dissidentvoice.org/2013/02/syrian-massacres-in-context/ two-part article, and updated as essay 7 in the above-linked CIWCL report. The "digital witnesses" provide video evidence that the rebels won the battle of Taldou that came just before the massacre.

Taldou Security Posts Overview 2.png

Victims

Main article: Houla:Victims

Both pro- and anti-government sources agree that the two main victim families were named Abdul Razak, with several subfamilies attacked and the most children among their dead, and two families named Al-Sayed, living near each other but not clearly related. In addition, a number of others were killed in fighting or by shelling, depending on the accounts.

The apparently targeted killing of those few families as opposed to random atrocities makes the question about their religious and political orientation central. While the narrative of a government/shabiha attack has no explanation to make them stand-out from the rest of the town residents, the other narrative points to a pro-government stance of the Al-Sayed's, including a possible relation to a member of the newly elected parliament, and describes the Abdul Razak's as non-Sunni Muslims (recent converts to Shi'ism).

Witnesses and their narratives

Two sets of witnesses with two contradicting narratives exist, which indicates that one set or another of the two has to be grossly wrong and therefore, most likely, lying in some kind of conspiracy. Therefore we refer to all of them as "alleged" witnesses.

General Government/Shabiha attack narrative

UN Observers and Channel 4 team enter Taldou passing the central roundabout with clock tower, a dead ungulate lying on the street[1]
Main article: Houla:Alleged witnesses for a government/Shabiha attack

The massacre was done by pro-Assad Alawite militias called Shabiha. They approached Taldou from south-western direction coming from the small Alawite villages there. They had help from the Army which fired on peaceful demonstrators at a checkpoint and, extent widely varying in the testimonies, used heavy arms shelling the village. The victims were massacred because they were Sunni Muslims and/or protesting the government. They did it to spread fear and terror among people protesting the Government.

This witness set comes mostly from western media sources. The number of alleged witnesses is higher than for the other, and most of them have names, but many were interviewed only by telephone or Skype and the contacts were made by opposition activists. There's one subset interviewed on the ground by Channel 4 reporter Alex Thomson who visited Taldou in the days after the attacks together with the UN observers, and one by SPIEGEL reporter Christoph Reuter who visited Taldou two months later on invitation of and "embedded" with opposition activists.

General Rebel attack narrative

Sister Agnès de la Croix-Mariam talking to RT[2]
Main article: Houla:Alleged witnesses for a rebel attack

The massacre was done by armed terrorist groups with help from local rebels. They approached Taldou from north-eastern direction coming from the city of Ar-Rastan which is controlled by foreign Salafists, and from villages on the way between. They attacked the checkpoints, took over the city and selectively massacred families loyal to the government and/or, varying on the testimonies, not Sunni Muslim. They did it to take control of the city, cleanse it and blame the government for their own atrocities to create international outrage.

This witness set, mostly anonymous, consists of one central subset interviewed by a Russian reporter team in Taldou in the days after the attacks, an additional set of refugees interviewed at the monastery in Qara, and a couple of indirectly reported others.

Timeline

Main article: Houla:Timeline

As a work in progress, this is an attempt to get more clarity by composing a triple timeline of events, comparing time-specific events as reported by alleged witnesses of both narratives, as well as those captured less ambiguously on video.

Investigations

Main article: Houla:Investigations

The Syrian Government, the UN observer mission and the UN Human Rights Council each have put more or less effort into investigating the events. For different reasons none of them are satisfactory.

False claims

Main article: Houla:Proven false claims

A collection of some, often early, claims about the events which turned out to be mis- or disinformation.

Before and After the Massacre

Main article: Al-Houla Before and After the Massacre

A rudimentary page of reported events before May 25, 2012, and especially after.

As of mid September, the area of Houla and east of it to Ar Rastan and Talbisah is the opposition stronghold of Homs province and remains under their control. Videos dated September 12 show the southern outskirts of Taldou with the National Hospital as a ghost town.[3]

Conclusions

Unknown people seen on the road to Taldou looking mean enough to be believed to be the perpetrators[4]

Ordinarily, believing those presented as witnesses to the events is a fair course of action. But in this case, there are two distinct sets of witnesses with two overall versions. Within each set, the guilty party is agreed on, one set blaming government/Shabiha forces, the other rebel/terrorist attackers overrunning security points prior to killing the target families. So far the investigation at this wiki has leaned towards giving the "government" (or "non-rebel") version a fair chance at coming together. There is also an effort to get the best overall reading of the numerous witnesses supporting the version most of the world already believes.

Just based on comparing witnesses, there could be little certainty. However, one of our chief findings is that the video record, more reliable than people in the little it shows, gives corroborating weight to one side and not the other. Interestingly, the witness set more supported by available videos (rebel-provided) is the one describing a "Free Army" attack on Taldou and a rebel-led massacre following. (see Houla, May 25: Who Was in Control?)

It might still be premature to announce just what happened in and around Taldou, but one fact at least is now clear; the anti-government version taken widely as fact must be questioned, and in place of that convenient certainty, a more thorough and neutral investigation must be carried out.

References

Main article: Houla references
  1. Exclusive eyewitness account from the Syrian town of Houla, Alex Thomson, Channel 4, uploaded May 30, 2012
  2. Syrian rebels took bodies from hospital to stage massacre - nun, uploaded by Daniel Burnet, June 16, 2012
  3. FNN Syria Homs al Houla Destruction in the area close to the site of the massacre 12 9 2012, FNN Syria Homs al Houla The occupied National Hospital 12 9 2012, uploaded by fnnsyrianews, September 13, 2012
  4. Houla, autopsie d'un massacre, France2 documentary aired September 20, 2012

External links